If we can't even keep illegal drugs out of prisons, we're
kidding ourselves if we think we can find a law enforcement
solution to the problem of contraband smokes. If we squeeze
an aboriginal reserve here, an illegal importer will bring
more in through the ports. If we monitor the ports more
closely, someone else will grease his palm smuggling cheap
product across the border. There's only one thing that will
effectively deal with the problem: dropping punitive sin
taxes. That's how the flood of contraband cigarettes was
stopped
in the mid-1990s, and that's the only way it will be
stopped now.
But if the price drops,
won't kids be more attracted to smoking? The important thing
is that if the availability of contraband drops, enforcement
of laws restricting the sale of tobacco to minors becomes
more feasible. Convenience store owners, after all, are much
more likely to be deterred by the threat of fines than
criminals are to be deterred by the slim chance of capture
by police.
And why, exactly, are we
taxing cigarettes so heavily to begin with? Yes, smoking is
harmful to one's health, but one's health is one's own
business. Yes, second-hand smoke is annoying and (maybe)
harmful to others, but we are all free to associate or not
with smokers and to patronize or not establishments that
cater to them―or rather we were, before banning smoking in
bars and restaurants came into fashion. Yes, smoking might
raise your future health care costs, but it might also lower
them by killing you younger―and at any rate, this is
actually a good argument against one-size-fits-all universal
health care. (See Adam Allouba's article
elsewhere in this issue of QL.)
The truth is, there was
never any valid justification for trying to manipulate
competent adults into giving up smoking by levying punitive
sin taxes on cigarettes. Now that we see that efforts to
curb adult smoking are leading kids to smoke, will we come
to our senses? If we won't do it out of respect for the
rights of adults to live their lives as they see fit, maybe
we'll do it
for the children.
|