On the Absurdity of Murray Dobbin's Carbon Fuels CEO Witch
Hunt* |
Mark Twain is often
(incorrectly) quoted as saying that “Everybody talks about the weather
but nobody does anything about it.” This is much less true today as a
large number of academics and activists are putting forward an ever-growing list of actions that range from carbon taxes and restrictions on
individual car ownership to jail time for oil industry executives.
A recent proponent of the latter is journalist and activist
Murray Dobbin.
In a column published a few weeks ago in both
The Tyee and the Hill Times, the self-proclaimed “popular
progressive columnist and analyst” states in no uncertain terms that our
“failure of imagination regarding the ever-increasing production and use
of fossil fuels will, over time, kill billions of us and irreversibly
change all life on the planet.”
Unfortunately, the “unimaginable wealth” and “sheer power of the
fossil fuel industry” makes it difficult to bring “the industry to heel
in a serious effort to slow climate change.” The only reasonable way
forward, he adds, is to treat it “like we eventually treated the tobacco
industry: as an existential threat to human health,” a “criminal
conspiracy” and “a plague.” Because the “fossil fuel empire” has
triggered a “slow motion apocalypse of global climate change,” Dobbin
calls for its CEOs to be (mock citizen) arrested on the “charge of
species murder.” What happens next isn’t entirely clear. Perhaps the
columnist wishes them the fate of thousands of alleged witches burned at
the stake a few centuries ago because of their supposed role in causing
the Little Ice Age…
Never mind that there has been no global warming for over a
decade and half and that our planet is now greener because
fossil fuels have been substituted for a wide range of
things that grew or grazed on its surface. Forget also that
there are now many more people than there were even a few
decades ago and that they live much longer and healthier
lives.(1) Indeed, Dobbin is apparently oblivious to the fact
there were barely one billion human beings around when the
use of fossil fuels took off and that the very notion that
“billions” of us might die is entirely contingent on their
widespread use in the last two centuries.
|
“Our planet’s climate will continue to
change with or without the burning of fossil fuels, just as it always
did before humans came along.” |
Another problem for Dobbin is that our planet’s climate will continue to
change with or without the burning of fossil fuels, just as it always
did before humans came along. And because people don’t like change, they
will find something else to blame. For instance, the author of
a column published in an 1881 issue of the London St. James’s
Gazette quoted American experts who blamed dangerous climate change
on the then-expanding telegraph system. Indeed, with “sufficient
electrical connection by wires around the earth,” they suggested, the
planet’s polarity itself could be reversed. The result would be a
“sudden melting of the vast ice fields” followed by a “glacial flood”
and “tremendous earthquakes” that would wipe out the human race. In
order to look somewhat reasonable though, the Murray Dobbin of his time
added that “whether this theory prove [sic] correct or not… there cannot
be a doubt that something has of late gone wrong with atmospherical
arrangements, and perhaps the telegraph wires are not wholly blameless
in the matter.” To his credit, he did not advocate throwing telegraph
industry CEOs in jail.
Closer to us, the geographer William Dando wrote in his 1980 book The
Geography of Famine that most climatologists and even a
“declassified Central Intelligence Agency” report agreed that because of
air pollution, the Earth was “entering a period of climatic change” that
had already resulted in “North African droughts, the lack of penetration
of monsoonal rains in India and seasonal delay in the onset of spring
rains in the Soviet Virgin Lands wheat area.” Global cooling,
Dando told his readers, was “the greatest single challenge humans will
face in coming years” because it would soon trigger “mass migration and
all-encompassing international famines.”(2) Who should be jailed for
this, however, he did not say.
Another way to put Dobbin’s fears in perspective is to consider past
reluctance to eat potatoes. Although consumed for millennia in South
America, the tubers were long despised by much of Europe’s peasantry
after their introduction because of their similarity with poisonous
local tubers, poisonous leaves and, in the case of some English
Puritans, because they were not mentioned in the Bible. In 18th century
France, potatoes were widely believed to cause leprosy, scrofula,
cholera, tuberculosis, rickets, flatulence and to corrupt the blood. In
19th century Russia, government orders to grow what peasants labeled
“Devil’s apples” and “Forbidden Fruits of Eden” on common lands provoked
major riots. In time, however, their undeniable advantages over
alternative grain and root crops—especially their high yields (between
two to four times more calories per acre than grain crops), nutritious
value, capacity to grow in poor soil and on small plots, affordability
and ease of preparation—proved irresistible.(3)
By any historical standards, Mr. Dobbin has lived a long and prosperous
(if perhaps bitter) life because of the fossil fuels he despises—and
perhaps also because he ate his fair share of potatoes. Apparently
unbeknownst to him, the apocalypse he fears is in the end nothing more
than what our daily lives would look like if our ancestors had listened
to the Jeremiahs of their time and turned their back on technological
advances and fossil fuels.
*This column is adapted from Pierre Desrochers and Hiroko Shimizu. 2014.
"When too Much Precaution Kills Humans and Wildlife: Part 1."
The Drill (August 27), A9.
|
1. See, among others,
humanprogress.org.
2. William Dando. 1980. The Geography of Famine, V. H. Winston
and Sons, p. 104.
3. See, among others, Ellen Messer. 2000. "Potatoes (White)." In Kipple,
Kenneth F. and Kriemhild Coneè Ornelas (eds). The Cambridge World
History of Food. Cambridge University Press. |
|
From the same author |
▪
Review of Animal Cities: Beastly Urban Histories
by Peter Atkins (ed)
(no
318 – January 15, 2014)
▪
Les souverainistes alimentaires font fausse route
(no
310 – 15 avril 2013)
▪
Beyond Locavorism: Food Diversity for Food Security
(Carbon-Fuel Transport Remains Essential)
(no
309 – March 15, 2013)
▪
Debating Locavores: Food to Energy to Smart Action
(response to critics)
(no
302 – August 15, 2012)
▪
Taking on the Locavores (with Hiroko Shimizu)
(no
301 – June 15, 2012)
▪
More...
|
|
First written appearance of the
word 'liberty,' circa 2300 B.C. |
Le Québécois Libre
Promoting individual liberty, free markets and voluntary
cooperation since 1998.
|
|