Montreal, October 26, 2002  /  No 112  
 
<< page précédente 
 
 
 
 
Charles W. Almond teaches computer science at West Virginia University at Parkersburg.
 
BOOK REVIEW
 
A MORAL AND RATIONAL DEFENSE
OF CAPITALISM
  
by Charles W. Almond
  
 
          In this powerful work, Dr. Edward W. Younkins provides an uncommonly clear and well-reasoned view of the close and always dynamic interrelationship between capitalism and morality. His argument flows from the most basic of all beginnings, people as individuals, and then proceeds to explain the close and dynamic interrelationship of our responsibility and freedom as free persons to the success and flourishing of all individuals in society.
 
          The author shows that the survival and flourishing of business as an institution depends on concepts and moral values which are the very foundation of personal freedom and individualism within civil society. He addresses ideas such as natural law, natural rights, individualism, private property, freedom, personal responsibility, the corporation, voluntary unionism, justice, law, and others. He further argues that these concepts are the foundation upon which a capitalistic society is built. Another refreshing approach in this work is the fact that not only does he discuss the effect of these concepts and values, Younkins clearly defines and discusses each of them in an easily approachable manner and language. 
  
          Capitalism and Commerce provides a systematic treatment of the conceptual foundations of business as it has developed over centuries through a number of disciplines, including philosophy, economics, political science, law, and history. The work introduces people to the idea of the free market as a moral institution with a very valid and compelling theoretical framework, rather than the more common perception of a merely pragmatic means of efficient production. 
  
          The book is at its core about freedom, and the discovery of the type of society men require in order to engage in their own pursuit of happiness. By not relying strictly on one school of thought and the inherent flaws therein, and instead addressing many different metaphysical and religious points of view, Younkins is able to offer the best of all arguments to make his points. 
  
          He draws his own principles mainly from classical liberalism, the Austrian School, Jewish and Christian economic personalism, the Public Choice School, the Chicago School, and the school of human flourishing initiated by Aristotle. His ten chapters on the "obstacles to a free society" will undoubtedly invite a tremendous amount of discussion. As a result of this approach, Younkins' book covers all the major issues in a manner that can appeal to people from various schools of thought. He is able to present the various systems that make up the world in an integrated, consistent, and natural fashion. He explains that freedom is an integrated whole. 
 
     « While the goal of this book seems like a huge and complex task, Dr. Younkins has broken it down into five simple categories, each building on the foundation of those before it, and leading to an extremely clear understanding of our political, economic, and civil society, as well as the interdependence of each upon the other. »
 
          I also think his clear, jargon-free explanations make his writing understandable to a wide range of readers. He presents the essential case for political and economic liberty in an interesting and highly accessible form. He writes that capitalism not only generates great wealth but also creates an environment in which morality and virtue can and should flourish. Civil, social, political, and economic society all thrive in a capitalist system where its members interact by mutual agreement and to their mutual advantage. 
  
          While the goal of this book seems like a huge and complex task, Dr. Younkins has broken it down into five simple categories, each building on the foundation of those before it, and leading to an extremely clear understanding of our political, economic, and civil society, as well as the interdependence of each upon the other. At the same time, he has done something others rarely take the time or effort to do; he has explained the flaws in the arguments of those who try to philosophically attack or discourage free enterprise. His presentations of the ideas of Rousseau, Kant, and Marx are superb. He addresses each of the common questions and criticisms that have been leveled about the morality or practicality of capitalism. His work stands out in its field, and will no doubt become a contemporary classic in the not-too-distant future. It should be read by every student, business professional, politician, and journalist in America and should be part of every college curriculum. 
  
          In my opinion, Capitalism and Commerce is a nearly flawless work! The only flaw, an easily corrected one, involves the presence of a typical number of typos for the first printing of a book. Since this book is destined to be around for many years, it would be in the interest of both the publisher and the reading public to correct these errors as soon as possible. 
 
 
 
<< retour au sommaire
 PRÉSENT NUMÉRO